Holiday rentals in Potsdam

Lovely private getaway place! So many amenities and the view of the lake is stunning.

You know when someone says "the pictures don't do it justice"? That perfectly describes this rental. An absolutely amazing house, with tons of space to hang out and spread out. Comfortable beds, plenty of linens, and thoughtful touches in the kitchen and bathrooms. I've stayed at almost 20 rentals in the Potsdam area and I think this may have rocketed to the top on my first visit. I can wait to see it in the summertime! VERY responsive hosts, including answering questions and plowing the MASSIVE driveway and shoveling the path to the entrance.

We had an absolutely incredible stay at Jay’s Airbnb! From the moment we arrived, it was clear that every detail had been thoughtfully considered. The place itself was everything we could have asked for—cozy, beautifully designed, and nestled in a stunningly scenic area with breathtaking views. During our weekend stay, we experienced over a foot of snow, but Jay had already arranged for a plow service in advance, ensuring the driveway was always clear and accessible. Thanks to his careful planning, we had no issues coming and going, which made our stay stress-free and enjoyable. Beyond that, Jay was an exceptional host—communicative, proactive, and incredibly accommodating. He kept us updated throughout our stay and went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable. If you’re looking for a perfect getaway with a top-tier host, look no further. We highly recommend staying here and would absolutely return in the future. Thanks again, Jay!

Absolutely loved the place very homey, beautiful views of Titus Mountain perfect for my family ski vacation. Denise is so responsive and flexible. We will definitely rent again when we need to stay in Malone NY.

Third stay at Butternut Bay, and it truly does feel like a home away from home. We have such special family memories because of Butternut Bay and its owner, first Jeanne, and now Meagan who is continuing her legacy--and it really does feel like that. Meagan cares that your time at Butternut is one you will remember. We thoroughly enjoyed her sharing of the St Lawrence Seaway map online, so we were able to track and learn more about the ships that were passing, day and night! Looking forward to our next stay, and more amazing family moments. Thank you Meagan!

We absolutely loved our stay here! The views were stunning from the moment you pulled into the driveway and from every window in the house! It was family friendly, our kids loved this house, the kids book shelf and the closet of toys and kid amenities! Anna was super responsive from check in day to check out! We were very happy with our stay and not only are we ready to go back, our kids are already asking for another vacation there!! Highly recommend!

My father is from Tupper Lake, so I’ve been here many times over the years. I needed a quick getaway to see family and hike Marcy. It was an amazing weekend and this house was literally the perfect place to come back to and relax after long adventures. Kelly was super proactive and communicative throughout the entire process. She made me feel right at home! It was easy to check in. The house is absolutely incredible with impeccable views. They did such a nice job preparing this house and I had more than enough to ensure my stay was comfortable. I’ve stayed in Tupper Lake 20+ times in my life and I would love to stay here every time I come up in the future. Thank you again for such an amazing weekend!

Great place, great host, great accommodations. Would recommend!

We enjoyed our stay here! Very cozy and quiet. We slept great on the king sized bed in a room with blackout curtains. The neighborhood was very quiet despite its central location. The living room was cozy and the kitchen had what we needed for all the cooking and baking we did. We’ll have to return during warmer months when porch and hot tub are useable.