Pet-friendly holiday rentals in Presque Isle

This beautiful and peaceful home was the perfect location and space for our family Christmas. The interior was country themed and we felt right at home. Doris was attentive and communicative. Will be back again in the summer! Loved it!

Very convenient to grocery. Very clean and comfortable.

Location was very convenient and easy to find. The Owner is very accommodating and responsive. A great value and walkable distance to the lake. Would definitely stay again.

Knot R Lake was great. beautiful view and a very relaxing place for a weekend getaway. 10/10.

Sherri was helpful and responsive. Place was clean, beautiful, and spacious. Stayed with a toddler and 2 dogs and place was great for both! We all enjoyed the grounds as well, despite the rain. Loved the covered porch!

I can't put into words how beautiful and relaxing this cottage is. The location is absolutely gorgeous and peaceful, but is just 2 minutes from shops and restaurants. The house is spotless, well stocked, and insanely comfortable. Our family of 4, plus our doggo, had a fantastic time!

The house comfortably fit my family of five, and was in a perfect location for us to spend the morning at Presque Isle and then drop into downtown for lunch. Daniel was incredibly accommodating to our somewhat complex check-in/check-out needs. He was very communicative. Overall an excellent host and an excellent house.

We stayed at Brian's place for a long, snowy weekend. It was perfect and exactly as advertised. We appreciated all the cozy touches including extra, soft blankets in the living room and space heaters in the third floor game room and the main floor bathroom. The bedrooms were comfortable and clean. We had a great stay!

We had the best vacation with wonderful memories. The most important part of our vacation was having a place to enjoy with our older dog who loves to swim. This may be our last summer with him and coming to Higbys was the best decision. They directed us immediately to the swimming area for him and it was perfect. Everyone was so friendly and went out of their way. Thank you for one of the best vacations. The memories will last a lifetime!

Our stay was wonderful! Great place for both adults and kids. Patti’s descriptions were extremely accurate. So many games and activities to do right at the home. One of the cleanest Airbnbs I have seen too!

Very cute cabin located within walking distance to the campground, little park, and Sally’s place. Easy to find and fit our needs for the trip.

Cynthia's home provided amazing views and beautiful sunsets. Our family vacation was memorable because of all the spaces indoors and outdoors that enabled us to appreciate the lake and natural surroundings. Cynthia was responsive to all of the little questions that popped up and we got to take advantage of so many restaurants and fun activities on Lake Erie and Lake Chautauqua. Our family of ten would stay again in a heartbeat!

Lovely little spot next to a lake. We were there in early April for a solar eclipse, but it was clear there would be lots of fun things to do in the summer. The neighborhood is tightly packed with little vacation homes, which is not my cup of tea, but other members of my family loved it. The cabin was clean, well maintained and perfect for our weekend get away. The view of the lake in the morning was peacefull and lovely.

Our long awaited family reunion of 8 adults and 1 dog LOVED staying in the Plum Bush house. The house is BEAUTIFUL and spacious, the beds comfy, the water hot and the sunporch was the coziest place to gather for conversation and enjoy the welcome snacks and beverages. The pool water was a balmy 88 degrees and the grounds were a great place to hike, have a camp fire or play a game of corn hole. Mary and Bert were nearby to answer any questions and made us feel at home. We would love to stay there again!

We had a fantastic trip and thoroughly loved the home and amenities. A gem of a find and we will definitely be back. Easy check in, responsive host, had everything we needed and more. The family loved the pool. Truly an amazing trip. Highly highly recommend.

I would highly recommend Peach Zen to anyone traveling to Erie! Francessca was a GREAT hostess. The accomodations were pristine and she thought of everything in the set-up of the space. My friend and I go on an annual Girls Weekend to meet and catch up in Erie and we will definetly rebook!

This is the second time that I’ve stayed at Michaels place. The description and pictures are exactly what you will get. Always a pleasure to stay there and I am looking forward to staying there again.

We enjoyed our stay at Robyn's cottage in the quaint Lake Canadohta community. She even let us change our dates & check in early! Had 2 fires at the fire pit, too. Comfortable bed. The Frog Pond Restaurant has a nice "hoppy" hour, which we took advantage of.

A cute house, with a cottage like feel. The host was friendly and communicated well. The neighbor we met was friendly. Everything was clean and we were able to check in early. The only negative was that the driveway is hard to find. If the host hadn’t sent us extra instructions, I don’t think we would have found it.

The cottage is in a perfect location for family to enjoy all the activities at Edinboro lake over the 4th July. Loved the smokeless fire pit. Great front porch to gather on. Would recommend this as a great family vacation destination.

Met some family for a short visit and the house had plenty of room. Kids loved playing foosball and the board games that were provided. Host was always quick to reply, friendly and helpful, and also gave us some local recommendations for during our stay.

Nadia's place is great and very well-appointed. It's so cozy and clean and well taken care of. Nadia was also really helpful and flexible during our stay when we got stuck in a snowstorm. She's a very gracious host and went out of her way to make the accommodations work for us on short notice and through many twists and turns. We loved the beds and couch -- so comfortable and nice looking!

great communication, very friendly and helpful. I would recommend this to family and friends.