Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Sterling Forest, Greenwood Lake

It’s all about expectations.. and they far exceeded mine. Host was very responsive, flexible, and pleasant. We booked last minute, but they stayed in close contact and got us in pronto. The home was spacious, well-stocked, and private, and our family loved all the things to do. We will definitely be returning!

This was our second time staying here for a family getaway and it was better than we remembered. The hosts were so great, very responsive and helpful. It snowed a bunch while we were here and they made sure we had what we needed and a plow came to help us get out of the driveway. The fireplaces are such a cozy touch and our dog loves the big fenced yard. We will be returning again!

Overall, we were very pleased with our stay. The kitchen was well-equipped, and we had everything we needed. While the living room was a bit on the smaller side, the spacious dining area made up for it. The only downside was that we couldn’t open the windows during a couple of warmer days. We did find one fan in a closet, which helped a bit.

Great Place! Was only there for one night, but made use of the hot tub, and great view of the lake, a peaceful one day getaway.

Beautiful house, well furnished, clean, so much space and beautiful outdoor area. Gina and Scott were fantastic hosts!

Nice peaceful , quiet place to getaway! Exactly what we were looking for! Coming outside to a yard full of deer that practically walked right up to you was awesome! Not to far from fun things to do, plenty of restaurants/diners around. Definitely enjoyed our stay!

This house is perfect for a nice, small, and quiet getaway. The house is spotless, with cleaning supplies available to use throughout your stay. The kitchen was fully equipped with utensils, cookware, supplies, and spices. They had everything you need to make full meals and more! The beds were very clean and comfortable with a great amount of sheets and blankets. The downstairs had a wonderful playroom and TV that is great for group getaway or children. This was overall a great stay and definitely recommend if you are looking for a relaxing place for vacation!

The home was very beautiful and clean , met all my expectations.

Bobby’s place was great for my birthday weekend!! It felt right at home and more ❤️ The only thing I can complain about is that there are barley corner stores lol but that has nothing to do with how great of a host Bobby was, thank you! I hope to come visit again 🙂

From the beginning to the end we enjoyed the place. Everything on the market for a kitchen is stocked. There were even condiments available. Cleaning supplies that I would buy for my own home was available which was greatly appreciated.

Lovely quiet, pet-friendly place above the garage but note that there is a steep staircase to get up to the second floor. Very friendly hosts - greeted me on arrival and had left the door unlocked so entry was easy and the key was available for my use. Comfy bed, cozy and warm rooms with remote-controlled mini-splits in both the living room and bedroom. Bathroom with tub and separate shower - the water pressure was not as strong in the shower as I would have liked, but it was nice to have the skylight in there. My GPS found it easily but a larger sign with the house number would be helpful, especially at night. I would definitely stay there again.

Good place to stay. The host was respectful and responded fast.

We stayed one week at Cecia‘s place and enjoyed our time there. It was easy to find, quiet and just as described. Cecia was very responsive, helpful and checked in with us during our stay. There are plenty of restaurants and grocery stores nearby. The bus ride to Manhattan is easy. We were really grateful for the option of a late check out since we had a late night international flight.

A great long weekend getaway! Loved the hot tub! Host was very friendly and responsive!

We needed a place to stay locally at the last minute and Suzette's place was available for 3 nights. Even being locals, we thought the location was premium, being very close to the amenities of downtown Peekskill as well as the beautiful Blue Mountain Reserve area. There is a walkable trail right by the house. The pet friendly listing was another bonus as we needed to be with our cats. We would definitely stay here again if we were in a similar situation, and I can see how out of town visitors would enjoy it as well.

Nice place, very comfortable and quiet. Have every you need for a pleasant stay. Felt like home. Our host were very responsive and helpful.

Highly recommend! Our stay was absolutely perfect and just what we needed to unwind and decompress. The peacefulness of nature and the seclusion of the property created a serene retreat from the constant hustle and bustle of our everyday lives. With perfect weather, we spent our days enjoying the firepit, making s'mores, and sipping on libations – a wonderful tradition that became a highlight of our weekend. We were conveniently close to the Shohola Falls, which was a great spot to visit, but the Bushkill Falls – Pennsylvania’s very own Niagara Falls – truly stole the show. Glenn made the whole experience easy, from booking the cabin to answering all our questions before we arrived. This trip was a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure, enjoyed by myself, my wife, our two teenage children, and our pups. It’s a long weekend we will remember fondly for years to come. Thanks again, Glenn! - Jon and Carolyn Bernstein

We absolutely loved our stay at this beautiful cabin. It was exactly as described and looked just like the pictures provided. It was very peaceful and relaxing and we hope to visit again soon. Susan was nothing but the best at communicating with us and all the little extras she provides at their cabin was just an added bonus. HIGHLY recommended!!

The cabin was absolutely adorable and exceeded our expectations! We stayed for my birthday weekend and it couldn’t have been more perfect. The cozy interior, charming details, and peaceful surroundings made it feel like a true escape. We brought our two pups, who loved exploring the spacious yard, while we enjoyed cooking over the fire each day. It was the ideal mix of comfort and rustic charm. Emily was incredibly responsive—she answered all my pre-trip questions quickly and kindly. After the trip, I realized I left my favorite hat behind, and she was more than willing to help track it down, which I really appreciated. It’s rare to find a host that thoughtful and a space that feels both special and homey. Thank you, Emily, for helping make this birthday one I’ll never forget! Highly recommend this cabin to anyone looking for a peaceful getaway with a touch of magic.

My wife and I enjoyed Johanna’s cozy cabin very much. It was very warm and tidy and it was easy to get around to attractions nearby. We loved hanging out by the fire and watching DVDs and using the well-appointed kitchen. A great stay!

The host was accommodating with our last minute booking and let us check in a little early. Thanks for hosting us again!

Our third time back because it’s just that good: the well equipped kitchen, comfortable beds, immaculately clean and well appointed house and grounds - such serene surroundings! Such a great spot for a reset respite. Meng and Andrew are so hospitable and responsive and have truly thought of everything to help one sit back and relax! We will be back again 💫

we absolutely loved Ben's place in the woods. we would come back in a heartbeat!

What a magnificent spot! If nothing else, the creek next to the house was worth the price of admission. But the whole experience was fantastic. We filled the place up, and had a dozen more family members come for Thanksgiving dinner. It was cozy and the extra kitchen in the cabin was a godsend. We loved being there, and everything about our stay was perfect. Thank you!