Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island Heights

This was a truly beautiful home that was perfect for our week along the coast of Connecticut. The home was impeccably clean and setup with an amazing bathroom and kitchen. Set in a peaceful area north of Niantic, it was a perfect place for my family and I to head out to many coastal adventures. We had close access to Mystic and New Haven with a short road trip to Newport. Jason and Colleen were wonderful hosts and have setup their place amazingly easy to get in and utilize. From the available bikes in the basement to the games my kids quickly found to play, this was a perfect place for us this week. Highly recommend to others looking for a great CT coastline getaway!

This home was so beautiful- I think even better in person than the photos, and the photos are already beautiful. We felt so at home, Cathy was helpful, responded quickly for any questions I had, gave lots of information on the area and recommendations for food/coffee. Highly recommend!

We loved staying at Ann’s place. Exactly like the photos, very close to Sag Harbor and the beach. The cottage has everything you would ever need! We would love to stay again in the future.

This lake house was absolutely beautiful! Brought my girls there as a little get away in preparation for my wedding day. Jhismery was responsive so quickly and so accommodating with some questions I had. Stunning view of the lake and the house had this homey feel to it. I would book it again as a weekend getaway again!

Terrific stay at Ellen’s lovely cottage. The house is warmly decorated and cozy. Amazing patio with outdoor fireplace and big gas grill. Fully equipped kitchen for gourmet cooking. The bathrooms are new and very clean. Lots of delightful and thoughtful little touches. A great base for exploring the North Fork!

We had another great stay at Claudia's place! This was our third visit to this location, and likely not our last. Thank you!!

My stay here was phenomenal! From the host’s response time, down to the amenities that were placed throughout the house. As soon as you walk in, it felt like home. The house is spacious and highly functional. The design of the house offers a perfect blend of modern mixed with nostalgic elements. The best stay by far. Would love to book again!

We had a wonderful stay! This is our second time staying in the home and both times Mariza was accommodating and great to work with. The house is in a great location on the water and is clean and maintained very well. We plan to stay again in the future!

Cute place, ideal for a couple. Location was perfect, next to coffeehouses, restaurants and bars and a short walk to the water. Most definitely will stay here again.

Viviana is a great host and very helpful. The apartment is very clean and well-organized. The apartment is especially quiet, which allows for great sleeping. Thank you for being such a wonderful host!

We stayed here for 6 days and it was the perfect spot! She had everything we needed & it was a beautiful place to spend our vacation. Erica was extremely responsive whenever we had questions for her. We would definitely come stay here again!!

Great location and fantastic host! The house was within blocks of great restaurants and the Peabody museum. The inside was clean, homey, and comfortable. We made use of the great movie selection and the kids loved the comic books! We have some new Foxtrot fans as a result :) Parking couldn't have been easier with the provided passes and Christian was so kind and flexible about our need for a late check out. In fact, all communication was prompt and there were thoughtful little touches throughout the property. We'd definitely stay again!

Patrick's place was perfect for us. The beds were comfortable, the kitchen had everything we needed, and it was spacious. It was nice and quiet - just the occasional car going by outside. The backyard looked pretty but as it was cold and rainy when we were there, we didn't have the opportunity to enjoy it. We'll be back!

Clare was a fantastic host. She helped us with getting around which was super helpful because we didn’t have a car. Her food recommendations were great. All in all, she created a warm and welcoming atmosphere which made our stay in Montauk a beautiful experience. Thanks for everything!

Great stay! Perfect location being 10 minutes from everything :)

Thank you Bob and Dawn for allowing us to stay at this beautiful apartment and allowing us access to your amazing back yard with the gardens, pond and waterfall. This is the third time we've stayed here, it is our "go to place " when we visit family in Milford. Cooper, their dog, is adorable:)

Place was amazing! Had a comfortable and peaceful stay. Is a beautiful home and close to everything that is needed. Loved how private it was and how clean everything was. Highly recommend.

We had a great time staying with Marina. The space was so clean and the perfect size for two adults and our senior pup. The outdoor space was beautifully landscaped and the beach was only a 5 minute walk. We would definitely come back!