Monthly Rentals in Gardiners Point Island

Petra is an incredibly responsive host, always available and ready to answer questions. The house is quirky (and I’ll say not maybe the best if you have mobility issues), but very cute and perfectly set up for our needs. The yard is excellent for dogs, and the location is also great, with a bay beach in about a 20 minute walk and a coffee shop and a few restaurants as well. Thanks Petra!

Our little kids loved this family-friendly, cozy home, and Marie was a friendly and responsive host. We visited during cold winter weather, but can tell this would be an awesome spot in warmer weather.

We had a great stay at Todd’s house in Laughing Waters. The house is spacious, comfortable and well equipped. Some areas of the house could use a little sprucing up. Good set up for remote work. It is what is outside that makes Todd’s place special—proximity to the small beach nearby (a great spot for young children), the quiet neighborhood, the water view from the deck and the large yard and garden. Great place to walk/run, bike ride, kayak and swim. Quick drive to downtown Southold, Southold Seafood Market, Country View Farm Stand, the Southold dog park and several Vineyards. Over the course of our long stay we had a few minor issues and several questions. Todd responded quickly and in one instance sent his property manager over.

Andrew and Kenneth were excellent hosts. Some of the most professional, responsive and attentive I have experienced. The home is cozy, and the space is really well used and appointed. Some of the appliances are a bit quirky -- like the washer/dryer, which isn't very effective; and the stove/oven which the hosts are aware needs some repairs. The location is lovely. Be prepared to listen to the ducks on the lake. They can be loud even during the night. The outdoor shower was the icing on the cake for me. I nearly stayed longer, except I had another opportunity overseas.